FAQ  •  Register  •  Login

User: Arth - SCAMMER (What a Scam Looks Like)

Moderator: Bladejunkie



Posts: 5

Joined: Sun Apr 29, 2012 8:39 pm

Location: Connecticut

Post Mon Apr 30, 2012 4:14 pm

User: Arth - SCAMMER (What a Scam Looks Like)

I posted wanting to buy a BM42, and this idiot attempts to scam me. Here are the details.

He contacts me less than an hour after I post my WTB:

Here are the pics he linked me to.






... this immediately seemed to good to be true - the pics seemed to be of an authentic BM, but they were too authentic. They look almost like promotional photos. you know - direct from Benchmade? of course not quite the quality... so I continued to speak with the seller.

At this point - I just wanted to agree on a price, before I started getting all paranoid, so I got that out of the way.


He responded fairly quickly.


Mint Razor Sharp? These knives are a couple years old as you all know, so this seemed to good to be true. Also - he was fine with $325.00. Didn't even put up a fight. It was only $25.00, however, so I continued to speak with him.

With a price agreed on, I started to probe him for some assurances that this was a solid deal.


His response was more than unacceptable.


For his vouches he links me to some random eBay account - with thousands of positive reviews and the same name (more or less) as his account on here.

This is the eBay account he showed me.


It had no visible history of ever dealing with any sort of knives / outdoor products of the kind ever. But I still entertained the notion of seeing this to the end. By now, I was extremely hesitant to continue the talks - but I really wanted a BM42 - so I wanted to keep this going until I was sure.

As for the second link he posted... He said that he couldn't show me the visible proof I had asked for with the knife, because he already packed it. To show me he really did this. He sent me this picture.


Because, clearly this box says it all... "See, here's the box. You can trust me." (He didn't say that but he might as well have.)

I wanted to play this out until I couldn't any longer. I asked if he could ship to CT.


He replied...


Davis... @ Japan.com.... Japan.com?! what the hell is japan.com....? I found nothing on google pertaining to this - and it just seemed very very strange to me. I never trust these sort of email domains. On top of that - He gave me that email completely out of context - so I didn't even know what it was...

This made me very very suspicious - so I decided to look at his account page (yes, yes, I know, I know. I should have done this first probably. Also I should have seen if he introduced himself... I'm new to that whole concept of formal introductions on forums - so I didn't think to look into it at first. w/e I did in the end.)

this is what his account page looked like.


Not sure if you can see but it says he joined the forum Apri 29th (yesterday) - the same time i posted about a BM42.

I then confronted him about my findings.


He responded quickly, and rather convincingly - but I still was not willing to give this guy a penny.


He then sent me another message saying:


^^ this I saw right through. His attempt to seem like an understanding, honest seller.

I then pursued the most obvious form of verification that I had overlooked.
The ebay account he linked me to.


no response from him after that.

Soon later, I received this private message from eBay.


Of course this made me absolutely sure it was a scam (not that i would've given him my money anyway. Too little assurance - too fake pictures - too good to be true)

hope you enjoyed this little tale. I thought it was pretty amusing.

Last edited by Zebra on Mon Apr 30, 2012 8:13 pm, edited 1 time in total.


User avatar

Posts: 1446

Joined: Tue Sep 02, 2008 6:55 am

Location: Lethargia

Post Mon Apr 30, 2012 5:37 pm

Re: User: Arth - SCAMMER

:TU: :TU:

Awesome post, dude! I enjoyed it thoroughly. And I'm glad you weren't one of the unlucky few that do get scammed by these guys. Glad to see you kept your shit together in the face of a NIB BM42.

I can only hope others will learn from this.



User avatar

Full of Smiles and Sunshine.

Posts: 2432

Joined: Thu Aug 14, 2008 1:50 pm

Location: Hellfast

Post Mon Apr 30, 2012 5:57 pm

Re: User: Arth - SCAMMER

deserved a sticky...

read and learn noobs.
"Loosey will throw down meat grinders in his wheelchair".

Slaver: what is -=BRS=- ?
DeadPuppy: the future for balisongs

i blew the lid off of balisong-techniques.com!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


User avatar

Posts: 523

Joined: Tue Mar 08, 2011 9:11 am

Location: Lewiston, ID

Post Mon Apr 30, 2012 6:11 pm

Re: User: Arth - SCAMMER

Looseyfur wrote:deserved a sticky...

read and learn noobs.

3rd place OKCA 2012


Posts: 19

Joined: Fri Apr 13, 2012 3:16 pm

Post Mon Apr 30, 2012 6:58 pm

Re: User: Arth - SCAMMER

I got this very same reply to a post I left! It's as though I you just gave me a play by play of what was about to happen to me! It can't get better than that. Good looking out! :blush:


Posts: 242

Joined: Wed Apr 11, 2012 8:31 pm

Post Mon Apr 30, 2012 7:13 pm

Re: User: Arth - SCAMMER

What a prick.....knowing so many people are really trying to find a b42 and leaching off of peoples desires....suggestion ...most of the forums ive been apart of required you to give you telephone and address before using the markets....only administration would have it but it migbt would help detour some od the scams...just a thougbt


Posts: 5

Joined: Sun Apr 29, 2012 8:39 pm

Location: Connecticut

Post Mon Apr 30, 2012 8:09 pm

Re: User: Arth - SCAMMER

No problem guys! Yea it was some fun putting this post together haha.

Hopefully this will help prevent others from getting scammed.

A lot of times the little things are the most obvious.

The second i saw that Japan.com domain - I knew this guy was full of nonsense.


User avatar

Posts: 170

Joined: Tue Mar 15, 2011 3:47 pm

Post Sat Jun 02, 2012 8:57 am

Re: User: Arth - SCAMMER (What a Scam Looks Like)

Dude as soon as you saw the Click-N-Ship label on the box you should have known, how the fuck would he get a Click-N-Ship if he doesnt know where its even going yet. herpin'n'derpin, good post though.

Piper Maru

Posts: 68

Joined: Tue May 08, 2012 7:16 pm

Post Mon Jun 18, 2012 9:27 pm

Re: User: Arth - SCAMMER (What a Scam Looks Like)

Mittens wrote:Dude as soon as you saw the Click-N-Ship label on the box you should have known, how the fuck would he get a Click-N-Ship if he doesnt know where its even going yet. herpin'n'derpin, good post though.

I thought the same exact thing, thats why that paper is covering the address.

Also this is a really great post, nice detective work.


Posts: 16

Joined: Tue May 01, 2012 10:38 am

Post Sun Jun 24, 2012 9:04 am

Re: User: Arth - SCAMMER (What a Scam Looks Like)

Also look out for a guy who goes by russeljohn@gmail.com.. he tried to scam me once, and i've seen posts of other people saying they almost got scammed by him to. They need to be stopped!!! :pirate_ANGRY:
The BM 42 is a God.


Posts: 7

Joined: Mon Aug 27, 2012 7:17 am

Post Mon Aug 27, 2012 7:32 am

Re: User: Arth - SCAMMER (What a Scam Looks Like)

A nice little tip for you guys; if you go to Google Images and press the little camera button next to the "search" button, you can search using a picture URL, or a picture from your computer. Really useful for checking if that picture is anywhere else on the internet.


  • 19 Aug 2014
  • 5:00
    Thanks guys I have a few that should be in today and tomorrow . Flytanium and a satin ti 51 those two I bought and some how a friend of mine of JD got me to trade him my Cook custom
  • 5:12
    It's a long story I was suppose to get a 29 knives with double insert moku ti and a Damascus werhawk tanto but the guy that traded me has a 29 knives with double blur
  • 5:14
    inserts and a weehawk tanto blade and flyfather and 200$ and he knows Matt like I do so I felt for himm
  • 5:15
    so I have to update my list have 4 expensive guys coming in this week and they look sexy the guy on bladehq I was talking to him on JD and there was 3 colors one of each solid and he held me the cold with black blade before they put them out should
  • 5:22
    be here today
  • 7:58
    sounds pretty awesome cant wait to see em. I'm jealous all I have left is a trainer held together by duct tape
  • 20 Aug 2014
  • 23:45
  • 23:45
  • 21 Aug 2014
  • 10:13
    whats up zoh
  • 23 Aug 2014
  • 11:49
  • 24 Aug 2014
  • 15:19
    Passed my msf course today =)
  • 25 Aug 2014
  • 0:43
  • 7:17
  • 26 Aug 2014
  • its been awhile since ive been in ghe forums lol anyone on?
  • 27 Aug 2014
  • 5:02
  • 28 Aug 2014
  • 18:01
  • 22:33
    tomorrow chivy buys a motorcycle >:)
  • 30 Aug 2014
  • 0:29
    Sweet, I know you have been excited about this for awhile. Post some pics!
  • 22:09
    I will once I actually get it =) they ordered new tires for me so I will have it like weds. I
  • 22:09
    I'm gunna go streetfighter with it i think though. I've always liked the looks of naked bikes plus the fairings on this one are pretty scratched up
  • 31 Aug 2014
  • 15:42
    don't know what exactly that means, but I googled it and it looks good.
  • 15:43
    make sure you get a pic somewhere for me to see though, maybe some replicant flipping infront of it once we get those too
  • 1 Sep 2014
  • 6:43
    for sure =) i'm just excited to have one finally. this is something ive wanted literally like my entire life
  • 6:43
    ever since I was a wee lad playing road rash on my sega genesis
  • 2 Sep 2014
  • 16:27
    Hi guys, it's been a while
  • 16:49
    I'm new but cool ass name
  • 19:47
  • 3 Sep 2014
  • 12:53
    motorcycle comes home today!
  • 5 Sep 2014
  • 13:48
    so lets see it?
  • 16:00
    I was gunna post pictures today but its stormy here. Tomorrow I will =)
  • 9 Sep 2014
  • 15:56
    hannam I posted pics on my fb =)
  • 18:41
    Selling a BM42!!! Check the Market!
  • 18:41
    Very good condition
  • 11 Sep 2014
  • 15:46
    don't know a ton about bikes chiv but it looks nice
  • 15:47
    it looks real clean and I like the color
  • 12 Sep 2014
  • 2:42
    thanks =) they started sending out replicants so soon I should be flipping again too
  • 2:42
    I like it a lot too. it was only 2k
  • 13 Sep 2014
  • 10:24
    I saw the exact same bike on campus today in blue and I have no idea if thats cheap or what for a bike
  • 10:25
    and reps are being shipped to bhq in batches of 25 so not too much longer, I think I'm between 100 and 150 on the list and they are up to 50 right now I believe
  • 14 Sep 2014
  • 15:37
    I would say 2k is cheap. I rode it on real roads today and another rider waved at me lol. it was so exciting
Log in to post on the chat.

Return to Trusted or Busted

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest